Equal inheritance can sound straightforward. Equal ownership is often more complicated.
The Del Vecchio family is facing that challenge following the death of Leonardo Del Vecchio, the founder of Luxottica. His estate was divided equally among eight heirs, who each received a stake in Delfin, the family holding company.
Delfin is a major shareholder in EssilorLuxottica, the company behind brands including Ray-Ban, and also holds stakes in several other European financial institutions.
Now, the family is facing a disagreement over what comes next.
Earlier this month, Leonardo Maria Del Vecchio offered to buy out fellow shareholders in Delfin, a move that would give him greater control over the family holding company. The proposal followed years of growing differences among the eight shareholders over the company's future.
Reports this month indicated that several siblings rejected the latest offer.
Leonardo Maria's offer valued each shareholder's 12.5% stake at about €3.7 billion, implying a value for all of Delfin of roughly €29.6 billion. That's separate from a reported €30 billion outside bid for Delfin from Czech billionaire Michal Strnad, which Leonardo Maria has said he was informed of but which isn't part of the sibling buyout.
The situation is a reminder that dividing an asset equally does not necessarily make managing it easier.
Equal ownership can create competing priorities
A family holding company can bring together multiple generations, investments and businesses under one ownership structure.
That structure works best when the owners agree on the major decisions.
But family members may have different financial needs, investment views and plans for the future. One shareholder may want to sell. Another may want to hold for decades. One may want a greater role in managing the business, while another may prefer to remain a passive owner.
When ownership is divided equally, those differences can make major decisions more difficult.
The challenge becomes even greater when the family's wealth is held through a complex structure of operating companies, investment vehicles and other entities.
Governance matters before a disagreement happens
Families don't need to predict every future conflict. But they can establish a framework for how decisions will be made when priorities diverge.
That can include clearly defining voting rights, management responsibilities, buy-sell provisions and the process for resolving disagreements.
It also means making sure family members understand what they own.
For a family with interests spread across multiple entities, that requires more than a list of investments. Family members and advisers need to be able to see how entities connect, who owns what and where decision-making responsibilities sit.
Without that visibility, governance becomes harder as the family and its holdings grow.
The family structure is part of the financial picture
The Del Vecchio situation involves one of Europe's largest family fortunes, but the underlying question applies to families at every scale.
Who owns the family's entities? Who has decision-making authority? What happens when an owner wants to exit? And does everyone have access to the same information about the structure they share?
Those questions are easier to address before a disagreement begins.
At MYFO, Entity Management and Stakeholders help families organize the entities, ownership relationships and people connected to their financial world in one place.
Because as family wealth passes from one generation to the next, managing the assets is only part of the challenge.
Managing the people and structures around them can be just as important.
Sources