Steven Gurney-Goldman, a grandson of the late New York real estate investor Sol Goldman, has asked Manhattan Surrogate’s Court to remove his aunt, Diane Goldman Kemper, as co-executor of his grandmother Lillian Goldman’s estate.
He values the estate at more than $600 million and says it holds roughly a third of the family’s real estate empire. He argues that Diane’s health prevents her from fulfilling the role and alleges that her sister, Jane, is making decisions on her behalf.
The petition is one part of a wider family dispute spanning courts in Manhattan and Delaware. It also raises a question that most families don’t plan for: What happens when the person appointed to manage an estate can no longer fulfill that responsibility, and who decides when it’s time for someone else to step in?
How a $2 billion family portfolio ended up in court
Sol Goldman was one of New York’s most successful real estate investors of his era, with hundreds of properties at his peak, including a stake in the Chrysler Building. After his death in 1987, his children contested their mother’s claim to a third of his holdings, and the court upheld her share.
Today, the family’s remaining properties are held through Sol Goldman Investments (SGI) and managed by Solil Management. Sol’s son Allan co-led Solil with his sister Jane until his death in 2022. Since then, Allan’s son Steven and Jane’s sister Amy Goldman Fowler have been on one side of the family dispute, with Jane on the other.
At the centre of the conflict is a disagreement over the value of the family’s real estate holdings. Steven and Amy exercised put options to sell shares back to the company, with the buyout price determined by an appraisal. A preliminary valuation put SGI at approximately $2.6 billion. The final valuation came in at about $1.83 billion.
Steven and Amy allege that Jane and Solil employee Louisa Little influenced the appraisal process, resulting in an undervaluation of at least $569.5 million. On October 28, 2026, Justice Melissa Crane of New York State Supreme Court denied Jane’s request for summary judgment, meaning those claims are proceeding to trial.
What each side is arguing about the executor role
The executor petition, which Steven filed in 2025, shifts the focus from the value of the family’s holdings to who has authority over the estate. It alleges that:
- Diane’s health has left her unable to understand and fulfill the responsibilities of a co-executor.
- Diane lives in Jane’s Upper East Side home, and Jane is effectively making decisions on her behalf.
- Jane has refused to distribute the estate’s properties to Lillian’s four children, allowing her to retain control over those assets.
Separately, Steven and Amy are seeking to remove Jane, Diane and Louisa Little from positions at other family trusts and LLCs, alleging breaches of fiduciary duty.
Lawyers representing Jane and Diane argue that the estate has been managed appropriately. They also point out that Diane approved more than $15 million in distributions to Steven over the past two years, and argue that by accepting them, he implicitly conceded she was fit to serve.
The allegations remain disputed, and none of these claims has been decided by the court.
What the case shows about who runs an estate
Most estate plans identify an executor and outline their responsibilities. Fewer address what happens if that person becomes incapacitated, how their ability to serve should be assessed or who has the authority to appoint a replacement.
When those provisions are missing, the decision can fall to a court, often after disagreements have already escalated into a family dispute.
The Goldman case also illustrates how overlapping roles can complicate matters. The same individuals hold positions across the estate, the operating company and several family trusts and LLCs. A disagreement over one executor’s ability to serve can quickly become a much larger fight over control of a family’s assets.
It’s a dynamic that appears in other high-profile family disputes, including the Milstein trust fight, where disagreements over trustee authority and distributions have also reached the courts.
Timing adds another layer of complexity. Lillian Goldman died in 2002, and Steven alleges that her estate’s properties have still not been distributed to her children. The longer assets remain in an estate, the longer an executor retains decision-making authority, creating more opportunities for disagreements over how those assets are managed.
Questions worth asking in your own family
- Who is named as executor or trustee, and who takes over if they can no longer serve?
- Does the estate plan outline how capacity should be assessed and who makes that determination?
- Do the same individuals control the estate, operating companies and family trusts? If so, are those overlapping responsibilities intentional?
- How are valuations determined when one family member buys out another, and who independently oversees the process?
- Can beneficiaries access a clear record of the estate’s holdings, decisions and distributions?
That last question matters more than it might seem. Disputes often escalate when beneficiaries don’t have visibility into what an estate holds, how decisions are being made or where money is going.
See how MYFO brings it together
MYFO brings a family’s entities, ownership structures, assets and documents into one place, giving family members and their advisors a clearer picture of what the family owns, how everything is connected and who holds each role.
Families can also store wills and letters of wishes in the MYFO Document Vault and share them with the appropriate family members and advisors ahead of time.
Book a demo to see how MYFO works.
Sources