Connie Milstein, an 80-year-old real estate heiress and former U.S. ambassador to Malta, says her family cut off the $125,000 a month she had been receiving from a family trust.
In a petition filed in New York County Supreme Court, she is asking the court to replace the trust’s co-trustees. She alleges they stopped her payments in the summer of 2025 to pressure her into settling a business dispute with her brother and two daughters.
Her family disputes her claims, saying she is not short of money and pointing to millions she has spent in recent years. The court has not ruled on the allegations.
The dispute still raises an important question for families with trusts: what happens when one person relies on trust distributions for income, while someone else has the power to decide when those distributions are made?
A family that has been to court before
The Milstein fortune goes back to Morris Milstein, who started as a floor scraper in 1919 and went on to found a flooring company. His sons, Paul and Seymour, built the family’s interests into a New York real estate and banking business. In 1986, the family acquired Emigrant Savings Bank.
The brothers later fell out after Paul and his son Howard sold real estate firm Douglas Elliman without telling Seymour. The dispute led to litigation and, after Seymour died in 2001, the eventual unwinding of their partnership.
Connie is Seymour’s daughter. Along with her brother Philip, she co-founded the residential property company Ogden CAP Properties. The New York Post reports that the family’s businesses hold an estimated $3.1 billion in assets.
What each side says
Connie’s petition names her brother Philip and her daughters, Abigail Black Elbaum and Joanna Milstein. It also seeks to replace Peter Grossman and James Sligar, the co-trustees of a trust established in her mother Vivian Milstein’s name.
Her filings allege that:
- The co-trustees stopped her regular monthly payments of $125,000 in the summer of 2025 to pressure her into settlement talks.
- Philip sent a notice demanding that her trust contribute $2.5 million to the family business by September 2025.
- Her daughters and brother removed her from family trusts, and family members used her time as ambassador to Malta to take control of her rights and assets.
Her family’s counterfilings tell a different story. They argue that:
- The trust was established primarily for Connie’s two children, not for Connie herself.
- Connie is “far from cash poor.” They say she spent about $23.5 million over several years, including $7 million on a Montreal home, more than $8 million on two New Hampshire homes and $3 million on a private aviation contract.
- She also sold jewelry at auction for $7.5 million.
The co-trustees called her claims “a diversion not based in reality,” and a spokesperson for Philip said the petition “has no merit.” These remain allegations and arguments from both sides in a case that has not yet been decided.
What the case shows about trustee discretion
Whatever the court decides, the case highlights an issue that applies to many family trusts: the person receiving money from a trust is often not the person deciding when that money is distributed.
When trustees have discretion over distributions, disagreements can arise over when payments should be made and for whose benefit. A beneficiary who depends on that income may have limited options if distributions stop, particularly when the dispute involves other family members with influence over the trust or related businesses.
The case also shows how quickly trusts and family businesses can become intertwined. Here, one trust is alleged to have been expected to fund a capital call into the family business while also providing income to a beneficiary who was in a dispute with the business’s leaders.
When the same people appear as beneficiaries, trustees, business partners and opponents in a lawsuit, decisions about money can become difficult to separate from the broader family conflict.
The counterclaims raise another important question: whose benefit was the trust established to serve? Connie’s petition treats the monthly payments as income she was entitled to receive. Her family argues that the trust was primarily intended to benefit her children.
Disagreements like this can be easier to navigate when a family’s trust documents, ownership structures and roles are clearly documented and accessible to the people who need to understand them.
Questions worth asking in your own family
- Who decides when distributions are paid, and how much discretion do they have?
- If a beneficiary relies on trust income, is there a plan for what happens during a family dispute?
- Does every beneficiary understand the trust’s purpose and who it was primarily established to benefit?
- Can trusts be called on to fund the family business, and who approves those decisions?
- Are trustees independent of family members they may eventually disagree with?
See how MYFO brings it together
MYFO brings a family’s trusts, entities, assets and documents into one place, making it easier to understand the structures they’re part of, who holds which role and how money moves across the family enterprise.
Families can also store trust deeds, wills and letters of wishes in the MYFO Document Vault and share them with the right people ahead of time.
Book a demo to see how MYFO works.
Sources